About Us:

Data Driven Detroit (D3) provides accessible, high-quality information and analysis to drive decision-making that strengthens communities in Southeast Michigan.

Why Shouldn’t I Retire in Michigan?

Making it through another birthday last Sunday made my thoughts go once again to the “Big R” – Retirement. While I can’t see myself giving up the “data business” entirely, nor divorcing myself from Data Driven Detroit, I do find the thought of a leisurely coffee (or two or three), comfortable clothes and some reading material an attractive alternative to a quick coffee (or two or three), a shower, a suit and a drive to the office.  I also see Michigan as my retirement base of operations (I have drunk the cool aid), with a six week stay during January – February someplace warm.

While developing the plan I came across a rather disturbing, though not surprising, finding in a study commissioned by the AARP, originally standing for the American Association of Retired People, but just AARP now – probably because membership invitations seem to get sent out to those younger and younger each year.  The move to letters, with no words attached, puts AARP in league with KFC.

I digress.  The survey was done by MoneyRates.com, a site that provides rates galore – savings accounts, credit cards, mortgages, and much more.  While the AARP recognizes that many highly personal factors come into play when it’s time to pick the perfect place to retire, they wanted to “add some objectivity to what’s otherwise a very individualized life choice.”  Therefore they had  the finance website looked at a number of factors, including climate, crime rate, life expectancy and economic conditions such as cost of living, job opportunities and taxes, to come up with their state rankings.  The interesting thing is that MoneyRates.com weighted each factor according to a poll that asked readers to rate its importance in the context of retirement. Based on their responses, the following weights were applied – economics (47 percent), climate (33 percent), life expectancy (12 percent) and crime (8 percent).

Well, with those measures as the base, it is not difficult to predict where Michigan might fall in the rankings.  Last you say?  Well…not quite.  We came in second last to Maine!  Let me give you the Bottom 10 in the list, and provide their account of Michigan.  After Maine and Michigan we have:

Massachusetts

Connecticut

Alaska

Maryland

Rhode Island

Washington

New York

Wisconsin

Interesting that there isn’t a great deal of winter warmth here, nor is any on this list a right-to-work state.

As for the comments on Michigan:  ” Michigan duplicated its ranking from last year as the second-worst state for retirement. Because it was similarly below average in all four categories, the reader weightings did not make much of a difference. Unemployment is high, and tax burdens are also above average. Michigan rated well below median for its climate. At 76.3 years, this was another below-average factor.  Michigan’s violent crime rate is also worse than average.”

It may seem strange, but after reviewing the data, and looking at what they judge as the Top 5 states for retirement – Texas, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Idaho and Louisiana – I will stick with my plan to remain here.  In spite of its flaws, Michigan provides me with almost everything I need to live a long and fulfilled retirement.  All I ask is that it understand that I just need a little “southern exposure” early each year.

6 comments to Why Shouldn’t I Retire in Michigan?

  • LakesState

    Why are these blog posts always so negative? It’s almost as if you don’t want anyone to come here, and suggesting that everyone already here have good reasons to leave. This is not how you go about rebuilding a state’s image.

    • If you read the history you will not feel that way. This blog points out a ranking and then states that I am bound and determined to stay. Negativity comes from the surveys and rankings that other people put forth. I suggest you follow the other work coming out of Data Driven Detroit.

  • Patty Becker

    One up for staying in Michigan, Kurt. Another ‘up’ for sticking with the data business part-time. Happy Birthday and enjoy your Medicare card.

    • A compliment? Wow! Please explain part-time comment…I would love to get the truth behind the jab.

      • Patty Becker

        Well, I for one am happy to be in Michigan in my senior years. We have thought about moving to the DC area, but it’s just too expensive. With global warming, our climate is getting to be more like, e.g., Cincinatti. We’re staying.

  • JM

    Even with Michigan’s recent tax law changes that now tax pensions, it’s still a better place to retire than many other states if you study the numbers and ratings provided by Kiplinger (see the interactive map at: http://www.kiplinger.com/tools/retiree_map/ ). As a Michigander now living in the south (for employment reasons), I can tell you the heat, humidity, polluted air and high air conditioning bills are just as onerous as Michigan’s cold, dreary winters. I’m hoping to move back to Michigan when I retire. When it’s cold, you can always put on another sweater; there’s only so much you can take off when it’s hot – and you’ll still be hot!

Leave a Reply

  

  

  

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>